Tim McDonald


118 games reviewed
69.1 average score
70 median score
47.0% of games recommended

It's not the reigning champion of this hybrid genre, but Mage's Initiation is a promising challenger. If sequels expand on the basics shown here, this could well be a series worth watching.

Read full review

An improvement on the first episode, but still marred by technical issues and. A move in the right direction, but it's still too early to tell if this is more The Killing Joke or Batman & Robin.

Read full review

6 / 10 - Virginia
Sep 22, 2016

It's rare for a game to make me swing back and forth a full 5 points on the score, but Virginia managed exactly that, and that's probably a sign of exactly how divisive this short piece of interactive story-telling is going to be. Let's settle around the middle.

Read full review

6 / 10 - Dishonored 2
Nov 16, 2016

Make no mistake: Dishonored 2 is an exquisite game that's likely to please anyone who enjoyed its predecessor. That's assuming they can play it at a reasonable framerate, though, and right now that's a pretty hefty assumption.

Read full review

Jun 3, 2016

A decent level that'll provide another dozen playthroughs of manic chaos, but not quite as organic or as manic as the past two efforts. Not at all bad, but disappointing after the unrepentant triumphs of Paris and Sapienza.

Read full review

6 / 10 - Shardlight
Mar 8, 2016

A perfectly enjoyable adventure through a dystopian wasteland, though one that misses a lot of opportunities and leaves a lot of tantalising threads dangling. Tasty, but not quite satisfying.

Read full review

Feb 23, 2016

Cleverly designed and rather lovely to look at, though a little slight, and not something that'll keep you occupied for long stints.

Read full review

Feb 29, 2016

A decent game, but nothing more. Far Cry Primal tries to differentiate itself from past Far Cry games with mixed success, managing some clever new tricks, but losing a lot of what made Far Cry feel special in the process.

Read full review

6 / 10 - Skyhill
Oct 6, 2015

Flawed in a lot of ways and with some ideas that don't seem fully fleshed out, but a gorgeous and idly entertaining roguelike romp nonetheless.

Read full review

6 / 10 - Hard West
Nov 20, 2015

A decent enough turn-based tactical game with a genuinely excellent atmosphere, let down by limited tactical options, poor mechanic explanations, and a number of issues that make it seem as though the lofty ambitions outstripped either time, money, or ability.

Read full review

Aug 29, 2016

Attack on Titan takes a decent stab at the nape of the series' neck, but repetitiveness, a lack of difficulty, and a high price mean it misses the mark a little too much. Still: if all you want to do is be Mikasa, swing around, and chop down Titans, you'll probably rather enjoy it while complaining. I did.

Read full review

This particular episode is more a shaggy dog story rather than something that goes for the throat, but it's building up promisingly towards the season climax.

Read full review

Nov 2, 2015

Porting issues aside, Batman: Arkham Knight is a decent enough game. It's not the spectacular swansong we hoped for from Rocksteady, but it's another solid - if predictable - slice of Arkham gameplay, with a couple of great sections along the way.

Read full review

Tex Murphy is back, and that's exactly as good – and as bad – as it sounds.

Read full review

Jul 25, 2014

Gods Will Be Watching is an interesting and novel little game, but one that's quite horribly flawed in a number of ways.

Read full review

Nov 13, 2014

An entertaining comedy adventure, but too many of the puzzles in Randal's Monday are too far from even its own internal comic logic to really make sense. It's a fun ride, but it's also liable to frustrate if you refuse to use any outside help to solve this time-travelling puzzler.

Read full review

6 / 10 - Contrast
Nov 15, 2013

Like its name implies, Contrast is a game with a sharp difference between its highs and lows. There's a lot to like here, but it doesn't make it all that easy to do so.

Read full review

6 / 10 - Strider
Feb 27, 2014

Enjoyable, authentic, and oh-so-cool... when it doesn't break.

Read full review

Apr 30, 2014

Child of Light perhaps doesn't shine as bright as it might, but it's nonetheless quite a dazzling sight.

Read full review

6 / 10 - Watch Dogs
May 27, 2014

Decent, but not great. Watch Dogs is certainly worth playing, but it's not even close to living up to what's been shown off since it was announced.

Read full review