Steven Scaife


107 games reviewed
64.9 average score
60 median score
45.5% of games recommended
Are you Steven Scaife? If so, email [email protected] to claim this critic page.
May 31, 2020

The world of the game may be small, but it brims with a weird sense of life.

Read full review

Jul 16, 2020

Though you encounter familiar configurations of levers and passageways and other obstacles, the mansion’s rooms all feel distinct, subtly interconnected in a way you likely won’t even notice unless you hit the load screen and see that every puzzle is coherently plotted on a zoomed-out side view of the mysterious mansion. Creaks hums along smoothly and pleasantly without calling attention to itself, to its sporadic detriment but mainly to its strength.

Read full review

Jan 24, 2021

Hitman 3, for better and worse, splits the difference between player freedom and focused storytelling.

Read full review

Mar 17, 2021

Mundaun's greatest achievement is the Swiss Alps setting that's brought to life with tangible vigor.

Read full review

May 20, 2021

While these limitations have the potential for forcing nail-biting compromises, the irritating micromanagement clashes with other elements that otherwise suggest a breezier game experience, like the rudimentary combat and the way the environment practically overflows with currency and crafting material. So much of The Wild at Heart elegantly sidesteps the usual pitfalls of a resource grind that it’s disheartening whenever it devolves into busywork.

Read full review

Jul 27, 2021

The Forgotten City certainly doesn’t need to answer the philosophical questions that it poses before it’s allowed to examine them in a narrative context, but the ludicrously tidy conclusions to the main story and most side quests feel like substitutes for any deep engagement. The game handily transcends its mod origins and tells an ambitious and thought-provoking story, but it eventually reaches a point where it doesn’t seem sure how to end.

Read full review

Aug 5, 2021

Further glimpses into this breathtaking universe are often reward enough for exploring the game’s multitude of alternate paths, but even GRIME’s level design is surprising for featuring a world much larger and more complex than it appears as you discover involved platforming challenges and optional bosses. Though GRIME emerges into an almost comically overcrowded genre, its initial familiarity and rigidity belie a world of intricate and formidable imagination.

Read full review

As for the MFN offices, they’re full of detailed memorabilia like posters, props, and episode scripts, to the point where simply taking it all in is perhaps the game’s main appeal. There’s a tangible love and care that has gone into making the game’s equivalent of Sesame Street studios feel plausible, as well as a clear delight in warping our memory of a show that opened up a world of imagination for generations of children into something darker.

Read full review

Jul 13, 2023

Other UI irritations abound, serving only to further complicate an experience at odds with itself for how much information it wants to communicate at a given moment. On the whole, Jagged Alliance 3 lays some strong groundwork for the franchise’s resurgence, but it often feels like a series of individual victories that fail to work in concert for something greater.

Read full review

But the non-linear nature of The Cursed Crew does have its virtues. There are some magnificent moments of discovery where you feel as though you’ve circumvented the level design by maneuvering the right character into the right position to bypass certain guard setups or parts of the terrain. Simply by spending so much time with the characters, you’ll hit upon certain combinations of abilities independently, fine-tuning new strategies all the way up to the end. It’s in these moments that you see what the developers are aiming for, and they suggest that The Cursed Crew could be a tentative step in an exciting new direction for the studio, even if those elements are more notable for how they might be refined in a subsequent release.

Read full review

Because Yakuza 6 spends so much time tying the story into knots, a strong villain never emerges.

Read full review

The additional timeline never really questions the naïveté with which Radiant Historia preaches of self-sacrifice.

Read full review

Barrows Deep is a shaky throwback that, despite occasional success in its stripped-down, straightforward approach, suggests that maybe simplicity and escapism has limitations of its own.

Read full review

Feb 16, 2019

The game ultimately seems less interested in the process of how humanity breaks down than its grisly end results.

Read full review

Mutant Year Zero feels most of all like a promising start for something potentially greater. Indeed, for as much as the game offers an intense, occasionally brilliant spin on turn-based strategy, it’s tough not to imagine how a sequel could improve the writing and the exploration to realize what is, at this point anyway, mostly just a lot of potential.

Read full review

Oct 31, 2019

The game is so zany and so mired in its traditional progression systems that it ceases to say anything of note.

Read full review

Make & Break is at its best when injecting variety into the campaign, not only mixing up the environments but the game modes.

Read full review

Nov 12, 2020

The game noticeably stumbles as it attempts to more overtly address the darkness beneath its concept.

Read full review

Nov 20, 2020

The Pathless ultimately buries anything it might have to say in a stupefying level of cliché.

Read full review

Dec 21, 2020

To criticize Cyberpunk 2077 for being hypocritical and conservative feels almost beside the point.

Read full review