Reid McCarter


75 games reviewed
69.5 average score
70 median score
33.8% of games recommended
Are you Reid McCarter? If so, email [email protected] to claim this critic page.
Unscored - Tearaway
Nov 27, 2013

Tearaway takes its developers’ aims further by coupling the tactile nature of touch screens with constant prompts to bring the player’s face, surroundings, fingers, and creativity into most every gameplay scenario.

Read full review

Unscored - High on Life
Dec 15, 2022

This uneven mix of humor and design keeps “High on Life” from ever feeling like a natural combination of video game and traditional comedy, even if there are plenty of moments where glimpses of some better blend of the two elements appears. What’s here is worthwhile for audiences curious about the concept of a comedy shooter, but it’s too uneven and stiflingly desperate to please to recommend beyond that.

Read full review

Oct 17, 2022

Though pandemic fiction may seem like the last thing audiences need right now, the catharsis “Requiem” provides is a valuable salve. It reminds us that others, today and in the past, feel or have felt our same confusion, fear and grief.

Read full review

Feb 2, 2022

Unfortunately, though, the narrative is a black hole of missed opportunities, surfacing time and again to remind players of what’s missing from the experience even as they try to forget and just enjoy what does work. If only “Stay Human” could navigate its story of post-apocalyptic morality with the same deftness as its assured, acrobatic protagonist.

Read full review

Unscored - Redfall
May 1, 2023

If this tone takes center stage in the back half of the story, combined with plot developments that add some momentum to the proceedings, it may be easier to overlook the game’s weaker aspects and appreciate it as a compelling narrative work. At this point, though, the town of Redfall is sucked too dry of liveliness for players to be invested in whether its vampires triumph or not.

Read full review

Unscored - Evil West
Nov 21, 2022

Still, disregarding the downtime spent on its charmless characters and bland plot, there’s an undeniable thrill to the fighting. If only the rest of the game packed as memorable a punch as its protagonist does when beating the insides out of Evil West’s vampires, it would be easier to recommend. As it stands, it’s not much more than a series of better-than-average monster-pummeling arenas interrupted by uninspired storytelling.

Read full review

Nov 26, 2013

Stick it to the Man is a game that seems almost too obviously referential to a subversive subculture to look as bright and be as assertive as it is. But that doesn't stop it from being as boldly weird (and ultimately super funny) as it is.

Read full review

3 / 10.0 - Wayward Manor
Jul 18, 2014

I have a feeling that even [Gaiman's] most devoted fans will be disappointed with the experience.

Read full review

3 / 10.0 - Daylight
May 5, 2014

The promise of Daylight—never feeling safe because random scares defy predictability—ends up seeming like the main cause of its problems instead of a genre-changing bit of design.

Read full review

Sep 21, 2016

the end, it's kitsch. It's a Soviet-themed Lego set that renders a monumental socio-political phenomenon into little else but a toy. And an exceptionally boring one at that.

Read full review

4 / 10.0 - DreadOut
May 20, 2014

Without either a compelling cast or plot, there's little to draw the player into the mundane gameplay.

Read full review

This is a game that doesn’t seem to care at all about the very real horrors of modern Central and South American history—that presents a dire international problem as something that can be solved through the clean precision of four American badasses pulling off sync shots. Whether out of neglect, a lack of understanding or a deep callousness, it turns the suffering of the people who right now live under vicious cartels into a playground for a forgettable sandbox shooter. Its audience needs either a willful ignorance of—or a disturbing outlook on—the world around them to be able to play Wildlands without a deep sense of unease.

Read full review

4 / 10 - Broken Roads
Apr 10, 2024

Despite the promise of its setting and philosophically informed morality system, Broken Roads fails to set itself apart from or come remotely close to matching the many post-apocalyptic games it's inspired by.

Read full review

Apr 10, 2017

There are a handful of good stories to be found in Andromeda, but they’re hidden away, worthwhile moments tucked within hours and hours of disposable ones. In an effort to be as comprehensive as possible in tone, styles of mission objective and purpose, the game ends up feeling as impossibly vast as nature but as rigid and artificial as a computer system.

Read full review

5 / 10.0 - Traverser
Jul 6, 2015

There's the outline of a great game one whose aesthetic would likely attract audiences young and old—but it only ever appears in glimpses.

Read full review

5 / 10.0 - Kholat
Jun 8, 2015

A certain type of player will find a lot to enjoy in simply puzzling out their location and trekking toward the objectives.

Read full review

6 / 10.0 - ZOMBI
Aug 28, 2015

Zombi's unique take on survival horror isn't enough to compensate for an otherwise bland experience.

Read full review

6 / 10.0 - Betrayer
Apr 1, 2014

The same design elements that give the experience [of playing Betrayer] such a wonderfully palpable sense of dread are misused to the point of tedium.

Read full review

Oct 6, 2014

As superb as the experience of simply exploring [The Vanishing of Ethan Carter's] eerie environments is, unravelling the plot's mystery isn't terribly enjoyable.

Read full review

Mar 22, 2015

Wrong Number, more than a direct continuation, is an expansion and affirmation of Hotline Miami's themes.

Read full review